ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   Non Scooby Related (https://www.scoobynet.com/non-scooby-related-4/)
-   -   Legality of barbed wire? (https://www.scoobynet.com/non-scooby-related-4/651360-legality-of-barbed-wire.html)

Deep Singh 02 December 2007 05:39 PM

Legality of barbed wire?
 
Is there any reason why I can't put barbed wire on the top of my side entrance and roof edges of my garage? the house (and garage etc) is set back at least 15 foot from the pavement (if that makes any difference)

Thanks

ps I know it looks horrid but want to secure my house as much as possible:(

girl-in-a-scoob 02 December 2007 05:41 PM

Law says No Im afraid.... all to do with people hurting themselves as they break into your property.

You could put anti-bandit paint on as once it is on you cant wash it off and the police can arrest you for questioning if they see people with it on.

bugeyeandy 02 December 2007 05:46 PM

A quick google search brings up this snippet from Grampian police


If you use barbed or razor wire, under the Occupiers
Liability Act 1984 you must take reasonable precautions
to prevent injury to other people, including trespassers,
caused by dangers on your property. If you are building a wall
on the boundary with your neighbour, you may need your
neighbour’s permission (under the Party Wall Act 1996).
If you live somewhere, such as an estate, where there
are building restrictions in force, you may need to get
special permission.
http://www.grampian.police.uk/Pdf/Ad...SafeSecure.pdf

exvaux 02 December 2007 05:47 PM

as G.I.A.S said its against the law in case anyone hurts themselves on it for whatever reason,leaves you open to being sued

Deep Singh 02 December 2007 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by girl-in-a-scoob (Post 7454630)
Law says No Im afraid.... all to do with people hurting themselves as they break into your property.

You could put anti-bandit paint on as once it is on you cant wash it off and the police can arrest you for questioning if they see people with it on.

Hi again!

Funny that, because I was at a friends house at the end of whose garden is the underground line. London underground have put up a fence with barbed wire between the line and the gardens. If they can do it why can't I?:brickwall

I take it the same applies to anything else sharp/dangerous ie spikes etc?

Thanks for the heads up on the anti bandit paint


Thanks for the advice on the roof btw, I've decided to go with timber frame/double battened/felt/tiles/lead flashing:)

Deep Singh 02 December 2007 05:55 PM


Originally Posted by exvaux (Post 7454651)
as G.I.A.S said its against the law in case anyone hurts themselves on it for whatever reason,leaves you open to being sued

I suppose it could also hurt the firebrigade/police if they needed to gain entry, which is a fair point. Saying that though if there was a fire I would presume the fire brigade would just hack the wooden side door down in 10 seconds

Deep Singh 02 December 2007 06:01 PM


Originally Posted by bugeyeandy (Post 7454645)
A quick google search brings up this snippet from Grampian police



http://www.grampian.police.uk/Pdf/Ad...SafeSecure.pdf

Thanks. That doesn't say its illegal. How am I meant to take reasonable precautions to prevent someone being injured if I'm using barbed wire, when the whole point of the barbed wire is to injure anyone who tries to come over?:wonder:

David Lock 02 December 2007 06:02 PM


Originally Posted by Deep Singh (Post 7454666)

........ I've decided to go with timber frame/double battened/felt/tiles/lead flashing:)

Have you seen the price of lead recently? That won't be there for long :D dl


(they've even done the lead off the roof of a school around here.....)

KiwiGTI 02 December 2007 06:15 PM

I though there was a distinction made between commercial and residential properties.

bugeyeandy 02 December 2007 06:23 PM


How am I meant to take reasonable precautions to prevent someone being injured if I'm using barbed wire,
It means make sure it's visible - ie you haven't dug a three foot trench and filled it with razor wire for someone to fall into.

Puff The Magic Wagon! 02 December 2007 06:28 PM

Interestingly, our house is surrounded on 2 sides by a farmer's field where he routinely keeps cattle. The top 2 strands of the fence are "protected" by 240v electric :eek:

There's a couple of little yellow signs warning of the electric fence dotted about but it would appear that it's totally legal to do.

I've only clobbered myself a couple of times :rolleyes:

Brendan Hughes 02 December 2007 06:56 PM

Deep, the trick is to use natural barbed wire. Holly trees or pyracanthus plants, or even brambles if you can get them to trail along the top. The best bit is they look "decorative". Barbed wire to me suggests someone has something worth protecting / nicking (and is easy to get over just by throwing an old coat over it) - holly just looks like they want a hedge. Spiky plants are recommended by the police, I asked them about it for my house 8 yrs ago.

Over here we use bourgainvillia - wooden thorns an inch long :eek:

Brendan

mart360 02 December 2007 08:01 PM

so how come m.o.d establishments & prisons can use razor wire?

Mart

gallois 02 December 2007 08:13 PM

it is not illegal to use deterrants, but it must be a detterant and not a deliberate means to injure, hidden or inconspicuos barbed wire is a deliberate attempt to cause injury as are the, imo, nutters who embed shards of glass in the tops of walls.

Scooby Soon! 02 December 2007 09:00 PM

The landlord of my warehouse has a electric fence all the way round his garden of about 2 acres, half of which fronts on to a main road. Its been there for about 10 years so far?? It has yellow signs dotted along every 20 metres.

hrness 02 December 2007 10:05 PM

house up the road has electric wire across top of his wall, his back garden at the side is next to pavement wall is about 8 feet

rob878 02 December 2007 10:08 PM


Originally Posted by mart360 (Post 7455008)
so how come m.o.d establishments & prisons can use razor wire?

Mart

We've over the last few years taken down the barb and razor wire. Just in case anyone hurts themselves breaking on to base. :cuckoo:

worley 02 December 2007 10:09 PM

Reminds me of my student days in Middlesbrough; glass cemented into the top of a wall - some house owners used to use it as a form of decoration - also kept the cats out!


Nik

Leslie 03 December 2007 10:59 AM

It really is quite disgraceful that if we do take such steps to secure our own property against burglars that they can sue you if they get a cut etc while breaking into the property.

What on earth has happened to this country when the criminals get priority over us when they are breaking the law!

Les :(

DCI Gene Hunt 03 December 2007 11:08 AM

You can do it, all this 'it's illegal' is balls....

As stated its covered under the OLA 1984, which places a duty of care on landlords/owners to protect 'trespassers' from harm. But ONLY harm that isn't obvious (such as a hidden danger).

You should place warning signs near the barbed wire that CLEARLY state that barbed wire has been installed, and also the signs must clearly describe this danger so that even a 'child' could also understand the danger posed.

You must be careful that there are no allurements, and that the fence, wall and barbed wire are maintained at all times. This is important as if you're aware of gaps in the wire and people crawling through these gaps you would be liable under the act for any harm caused to them.

There are several case laws surrounding this (trespass) and as long as you stop short of laying landmines you'll be fine :thumb:

Leslie 03 December 2007 11:11 AM

Still a ridiculous situation.

Les

DCI Gene Hunt 03 December 2007 11:19 AM


Originally Posted by Leslie (Post 7456241)
Still a ridiculous situation.

Les

Agreed 100% Les...

Deep Singh 03 December 2007 11:29 AM

Thanks to all. Barbed wire it is then. It will be clearly visible and at its lowest point will be approx 8 foot off the ground so there is no possibilty of anyone being caught up in it 'accidentally' ie children playing etc

Brendans idea is good though and I'll investigate that further

Abdabz 03 December 2007 12:33 PM


Originally Posted by DCI Gene Hunt (Post 7456235)
You can do it, all this 'it's illegal' is balls....

As stated its covered under the OLA 1984, which places a duty of care on landlords/owners to protect 'trespassers' from harm. But ONLY harm that isn't obvious (such as a hidden danger).

You should place warning signs near the barbed wire that CLEARLY state that barbed wire has been installed, and also the signs must clearly describe this danger so that even a 'child' could also understand the danger posed.

You must be careful that there are no allurements, and that the fence, wall and barbed wire are maintained at all times. This is important as if you're aware of gaps in the wire and people crawling through these gaps you would be liable under the act for any harm caused to them.

There are several case laws surrounding this (trespass) and as long as you stop short of laying landmines you'll be fine :thumb:

That's exactly what I was about to type :idea:

It is very legal, all you need to do is put up signage... I looked into this quite seriously when I was renting a scumpit in a scumpit area about 8 years ago...

j4ckos mate 03 December 2007 01:48 PM

have you thought about carpet gripper rods, they can be treated the same colour as the fence

Deep Singh 03 December 2007 04:08 PM


Originally Posted by j4ckos mate (Post 7456467)
have you thought about carpet gripper rods, they can be treated the same colour as the fence

They would be more difficult to see and therefore be 'concealed', hence more chance of being sued

POC 03 December 2007 04:15 PM

We put it up all the time Deep, residential, comercial and agricultural, make sure you put up warning signs.

_Meridian_ 03 December 2007 05:00 PM


Originally Posted by Puff The Magic Wagon! (Post 7454755)
Interestingly, our house is surrounded on 2 sides by a farmer's field where he routinely keeps cattle. The top 2 strands of the fence are "protected" by 240v electric :eek:



12V or less. I think there are a couple of 24V systems, but most run off a car battery or a rechargeable 9v battery. You can hold the wire for several seconds without too much pain - we used to play that game when I was about 7. I seriously advise you not to pee on one though...


M

[Davey] 03 December 2007 05:31 PM


Originally Posted by Deep Singh (Post 7454666)
Hi again!

Funny that, because I was at a friends house at the end of whose garden is the underground line. London underground have put up a fence with barbed wire between the line and the gardens. If they can do it why can't I?:brickwall

I take it the same applies to anything else sharp/dangerous ie spikes etc?

They have liability insurance, you dont :thumb:

AFAIK its not illegal to use it if you make it clear its there BUT you can be held liable for injury..

DCI Gene Hunt 03 December 2007 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by [Davey] (Post 7456916)
They have liability insurance, you dont :thumb:

AFAIK its not illegal to use it if you make it clear its there BUT you can be held liable for injury..

Its not illegal full stop, the only difference is that if you fail to adequatley warn trespassers then you will be liable if they are harmed.. but only to the person, not property...


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:55 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands